Redirect and forward look like twins in the Outlook on the web rules menu, but they behave very differently once mail leaves your mailbox. If you run domain email on Microsoft 365 and want a copy of every message to land in Gmail or another outside address, the rule you pick decides whether replies come back to the original sender or to you. Here is the exact build, plus the trade-offs worth knowing before you save the rule.

Build the inbox rule in Outlook on the web

Sign in at outlook.office.com with the Microsoft 365 account tied to your domain. Open Settings (the gear icon), choose Mail, then Rules, and click Add new rule. Give it a name you will recognize later, something like “Copy to Gmail” beats “Rule 1” when you audit rules six months from now.

Set the condition to Apply to all messages if you want a full mirror, or narrow it with a sender, subject, or keyword filter. In the action list, choose Redirect to and type the external destination. Save, then confirm the rule is enabled. Send yourself a test message from a personal account and check the destination inbox for it.

One quirk: Outlook on the web may warn that redirecting to external addresses is blocked by your organization’s policy. That is Microsoft 365 doing its job. Automatic external forwarding and redirects are restricted by default at the tenant level, so an admin has to allow it in the Microsoft 365 Defender portal under outbound spam policy. If you are the admin, enable automatic forwarding there. If you are not, ask whoever is.

Why redirect beats forward for most setups

Redirect preserves the original sender in the message header. The copy arriving at Gmail shows the real person who wrote to you, so hitting Reply goes back to them, not to your own address. Forward rewrites the From header to you and wraps the original inside the body, which means a careless reply lands in your own inbox instead of the sender’s.

That same header difference affects spam scoring. A redirected message keeps its original authentication context, so Gmail and other filters judge it on the sender’s reputation. A forwarded copy looks like a fresh message from your domain, and if SPF, DKIM, or DMARC are not aligned, it can score worse or even land in spam. For domain email, redirect is usually the cleaner choice.

Redirect also keeps threading intact at the destination. Replies to a redirected message slot into the same conversation, which makes Gmail search and labels far more useful. Forwarded copies tend to start new threads every time, and after a few weeks the destination inbox turns into a pile of disconnected messages.

Compare options before you commit

Outlook rules are not the only path to get GoDaddy email forwarding working. If your domain’s mail runs on GoDaddy rather than Microsoft 365, the picture changes. GoDaddy retired Workspace Email, and the company no longer bundles free email forwarding with domains the way it once did. Email Forwarding now requires existing forwarding credits, and as explained at allmail.one/blog/godaddy-email-forwarding, GoDaddy updates its help pages frequently, so check the current terms before you plan around it.

GoDaddy’s Professional Email, powered by Titan, offers external forwarding on Pro Plus, Premium, and Ultra plans. Lower tiers do not include it. Professional Email also gives you an Email & Office Dashboard for managing mailboxes, aliases, and forwarding destinations in one place. Email Forwarding itself is independent of other GoDaddy email products, so users can forward mail without a GoDaddy email product at all, as long as credits are in place. A catch-all address and email aliases both route through the same forwarding system.

If you are on Microsoft 365 and only need a copy of incoming mail elsewhere, the Outlook rule is the lightest option. If you want a full mailbox replacement, a distribution group or a dedicated forwarder service may fit better. Either way, test with a real message from an outside sender before you rely on it. The rule does not fire on messages already in the inbox, and it will not catch mail routed through a separate transport rule.

Run through this checklist before you walk away: rule enabled and named clearly, test message delivered to the destination, reply from the destination reaching the original sender, and an admin check on external forwarding policy if the rule was blocked. Keep a note of which rule handles which destination, because stacking several redirects on one mailbox gets confusing fast. If your domain mail still lives on GoDaddy rather than Microsoft 365, confirm your plan’s forwarding terms first. GoDaddy’s help pages change often, and a quick read now saves a support ticket later.